Very partial list of errors defined in smithy S3 model

Hi

For context:

• I am working on this project that uses the S3 model to interact with S3 clients and servers - https://github.com/s3d-rs/s3d.
• This is a followup from https://github.com/awslabs/smithy-rs/issues/1150.

When I look at the S3 smithy model, I find that it lacks a lot of error definitions for operations. Here is a list of all the operations that have errors defined:

$ node -e 'm=require("./smithy-rs/aws/sdk/aws-models/s3.json"); Object.entries(m.shapes).forEach(([n,s])=>{ if (s.type==="operation" && s.errors) console.log(n, "---", s.errors.map(x=>x.target).join(",")); })'
com.amazonaws.s3#AbortMultipartUpload --- com.amazonaws.s3#NoSuchUpload
com.amazonaws.s3#CopyObject --- com.amazonaws.s3#ObjectNotInActiveTierError
com.amazonaws.s3#CreateBucket --- com.amazonaws.s3#BucketAlreadyExists,com.amazonaws.s3#BucketAlreadyOwnedByYou
com.amazonaws.s3#GetObject --- com.amazonaws.s3#InvalidObjectState,com.amazonaws.s3#NoSuchKey
com.amazonaws.s3#GetObjectAcl --- com.amazonaws.s3#NoSuchKey
com.amazonaws.s3#HeadBucket --- com.amazonaws.s3#NotFound
com.amazonaws.s3#HeadObject --- com.amazonaws.s3#NotFound
com.amazonaws.s3#ListObjects --- com.amazonaws.s3#NoSuchBucket
com.amazonaws.s3#ListObjectsV2 --- com.amazonaws.s3#NoSuchBucket
com.amazonaws.s3#PutObjectAcl --- com.amazonaws.s3#NoSuchKey
com.amazonaws.s3#RestoreObject --- com.amazonaws.s3#ObjectAlreadyInActiveTierError

This is clearly a tiny fraction of the real errors that this API can return. See https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/API/ErrorResponses.html

Is there a way to contribute to the model definition to make it represent the S3 errors correctly?

Thanks!

[kellertk]

Hi there. Since this is a cross-SDK issue I’ve created a tracking issue at aws/aws-sdk#376. Please follow that issue for updates instead.

[guymguym]

Thank you @gosar - I really appreciate your update.