Samsung - alarm_stream notifications still silent

Home Assistant Android version: beta-637-94e1f15

Android version: 11

Phone model: SM-G991U

Home Assistant version: 2021.3.4

Last working Home Assistant release (if known):

Description of problem: alarm_stream notifications still silent installing latest beta and fresh start. Configuration below:

type: button
tap_action:
  confirmation:
    text: Find Phone?
  action: call-service
  service: notify.mobile_app_s21r8
  service_data:
    title: Finding Phone
    message: Ringing phone
    data:
      ttl: 0
      importance: high
      priority: high
      tag: Find
      channel: alarm_stream
name: Find S21
icon: 'mdi:cellphone-wireless'

Traceback (if applicable, to get the logs you may refer to: https://companion.home-assistant.io/docs/troubleshooting/faqs/#android-crash-logs):

[03-29 15:55:48.322 21235:31640 D/MessagingService]
From: 331041709873

[03-29 15:55:48.323 21235:31640 D/MessagingService]
Message data payload: {tag=Find, title=Finding Phone, channel=alarm_stream, message=Ringing phone, importance=high}

[03-29 15:55:48.325 1740:4671 D/SamsungAlarmManager]
Cancel Alarm calling from uid:10245 pid :3068 / OP:PendingIntent{d45bbac: PendingIntentRecord{12521f2 com.google.android.gms/com.google.android.gms.gcm broadcastIntent}}

[03-29 15:55:48.325 1740:4671 I/SamsungAlarmManager]
setLocked to kernel - T:2 / 20210329T155852, set=30546841, now=30362501

[03-29 15:55:48.326 1740:4671 I/SamsungAlarmManager]
setLocked to kernel - T:3 / 20210329T155559, set=30373189, now=30362501

[03-29 15:55:48.329 21235:21235 D/MessagingService]
Creating notification with following data: {tag=Find, title=Finding Phone, channel=alarm_stream, message=Ringing phone, importance=high}

[03-29 15:55:48.334 21235:21235 D/RingtoneManager]
getActualDefaultRingtoneUri  type    :4

[03-29 15:55:48.335 21235:21235 I/RingtoneManager]
Ringtone value : content://media/internal/audio/media/110?title=Homecoming&canonical=1

[03-29 15:55:48.336 21235:21235 D/RingtoneManager]
getActualDefaultRingtoneUri  type    :4

[03-29 15:55:48.336 21235:21235 I/RingtoneManager]
Ringtone value : content://media/internal/audio/media/110?title=Homecoming&canonical=1

[03-29 15:55:48.342 4325:4325 D/BoundBrokerSvc]
onBind: Intent { act=com.google.android.gms.measurement.START pkg=com.google.android.gms }

[03-29 15:55:48.342 4325:4325 D/BoundBrokerSvc]
Loading bound service for intent: Intent { act=com.google.android.gms.measurement.START pkg=com.google.android.gms }

[03-29 15:55:48.342 21235:21235 D/MessagingService]
Show notification with tag "Find" and id "2189785"

[03-29 15:55:48.345 1740:2484 D/ApplicationPolicy]
isStatusBarNotificationAllowedAsUser: packageName = io.homeassistant.companion.android,userId = 0

[03-29 15:55:48.345 1740:2484 D/PersonaManagerAdapter]
ContainerOnlyMode - EOS

[03-29 15:55:48.345 1740:1794 D/SettingsProvider]
isChangeAllowed() : name = enabled_notification_listeners

[03-29 15:55:48.345 1740:1794 D/SettingsProvider]
isChangeAllowed() : name = enabled_notification_assistant

[03-29 15:55:48.345 1740:1794 D/SettingsProvider]
isChangeAllowed() : name = enabled_notification_policy_access_packages

[03-29 15:55:48.346 1740:2484 D/ApplicationPolicy]
isStatusBarNotificationAllowedAsUser: packageName = io.homeassistant.companion.android,userId = 0

[03-29 15:55:48.346 1740:2484 D/PersonaManagerAdapter]
ContainerOnlyMode - EOS

[03-29 15:55:48.383 1740:4671 D/SamsungAlarmManager]
Cancel Alarm calling from uid:10245 pid :4325 / OP:PendingIntent{71a70e5: PendingIntentRecord{b070f9c com.google.android.gms/com.google.android.gms.measurement broadcastIntent}}

[03-29 15:55:48.457 2394:2511 D/NetworkController.SecMobileSignalController(0/1)]
onDataActivity: direction=3

[03-29 15:55:48.459 2394:2511 D/MobileSignalIconsSelector]
getDataIconGroup(): connected=true,enabled=true,level=5,inetCondition=1,dataIconGroup=DataIconGroup(5G_TMO),activityIn=true,activityOut=true,lastModified=03-29 15:55:48.458,dataSim=true,networkName=T-Mobile,networkNameData=T-Mobile,dataConnected=true,roaming=false,isDefault=true,isEmergency=false,airplaneMode=false,carrierNetworkChangeMode=false,userSetup=true,defaultDataOff=false,cdmaEriIconIndex=-1,cdmaEriIconMode=-1,callState=0,voWifiConnected=false,shouldShowDisabledDataIcon=false,bluetoothTethered=false,isLTEFemtoCell=false,cardOperator=OTHERS,optionalRadioTech=0,isCAIndicator=false,isLimitedStateForCTCSlaveVoLTE=false,isSWRoaming=false,isMobileDataSettingEnabled=false,nwBoosterRilEnabled=false,nwBoosterSettingEnabled=false,emergencyModeActivated=false,ismmW5G=false, iconSet = null

[03-29 15:55:48.459 2394:2394 D/StatusbarSignalPolicy]
setMobileDataIndicators state = MobileIconState(subId=1, strengthId=2131233570, roaming=false, typeId=2131233374, visible=true, activityId=0, roamingId=0, slotId=0)

[03-29 15:55:48.490 1012:27998 I/sensors-hal]
handle_sns_client_event:182, auto_rotation_event: mode:255, type:1:0/0.010,0.065,9.882

[03-29 15:55:48.517 1028:1120 I/vendor.qti.hardware.perf@2.2-service]
drmIOCTLLib connectorId: 55

[03-29 15:55:48.518 1028:1120 I/vendor.qti.hardware.perf@2.2-service]
drmIOCTLLib ret: 0

[03-29 15:55:48.518 886:886 E/audit]
type=1400 audit(1617051348.513:28926): avc:  denied  { sys_admin } for  pid=1028 comm="perf@2.2-servic" capability=21  scontext=u:r:vendor_hal_perf_default:s0 tcontext=u:r:vendor_hal_perf_default:s0 tclass=capability permissive=0 SEPF_SM-G991U_11_0007 audit_filtered

[03-29 15:55:48.518 1028:1120 I/vendor.qti.hardware.perf@2.2-service]
drmIOCTLLib close return 0

[03-29 15:55:48.548 1740:1740 I/NotificationService]
RuneStone mIsRuneStoneSupported = true, mIsRuneStoneEnabled = false

[03-29 15:55:48.552 1740:1740 I/AccessibilityManager]
semStartFlashNotification notitype = alarm

[03-29 15:55:48.552 1740:1740 D/AccessibilityManagerService]
semStartFlashNotification

[03-29 15:55:48.552 1740:1740 I/AccessibilityManagerService]
semStartFlashNotificationInner() type=Default, pkgName=android, token=android.os.Binder@226e1c6

[03-29 15:55:48.552 1740:1740 D/AccessibilityManagerService]
Can not use light notification

[03-29 15:55:48.555 1740:1740 D/EdgeLightingManager]
isCallingUserSupported : callingUserId=0, mUserId=0, isDualAppId=false, isKnoxId=false

[03-29 15:55:48.555 1740:1740 D/EdgeLightingManager]
showForNotification : isInteractive=true, isHeadUp=true, color=0, canBypassDnd=false, sbn = StatusBarNotification(pkg=io.homeassistant.companion.android user=UserHandle{0} id=2189785 tag=Find key=0|io.homeassistant.companion.android|2189785|Find|10291: Notification(channel=alarm_stream shortcut=null contentView=null vibrate=null sound=null defaults=0x0 flags=0x10 color=0xff03a9f4 category=alarm vis=PRIVATE semFlags=0x0 semPriority=0 semMissedCount=0))

[03-29 15:55:48.555 1740:1740 D/EdgeLightingClientManager]
isAvailableEdgeLighting: condition=1 mCondition=3 mIsConnected=false0

[03-29 15:55:48.555 1740:1740 D/EdgeLightingManager]
showForNotificationScreenOn : return false by isAvailableEdgeLighting.

[03-29 15:55:48.567 2736:2736 I/Launcher.NotificationListener]
onNotificationPosted : io.homeassistant.companion.android number : 0

[03-29 15:55:48.567 2736:2852 I/Launcher.NotificationListener]
notificationIsValidForUI : io.homeassistant.companion.android missingTitleAndText : false isGroupHeader : false

[03-29 15:55:48.576 2394:2394 D/InterruptionStateProvider]
No bubble up: not allowed to bubble: 0|io.homeassistant.companion.android|2189785|Find|10291

[03-29 15:55:48.577 2394:2394 W/NotifBindPipeline]
Row is not set so pipeline will not run. notif = 0|io.homeassistant.companion.android|2189785|Find|10291

Screenshot of problem:

Additional information:

[dshokouhi]

@dshokouhi I have a samsung tablet. Can i help you with debugging?

I suppose we could add some more debug logs but based on what I see in the logs above the ringtone URI is successfully retrieved but the notification call strips it out for some reason. I dont know if its something samsung has done to the actual notification API or not but I know resorting to media player/ringtone player is not desireable as the audio wont stop naturally like it does on my pixel. Honestly not really sure where to start with it, everything about hte code suggests it should work. Based on the logs above I know my assumption was correct in that the default alarm ringtone was null but not sure why the ringtone itself wont work when its not null.

https://github.com/home-assistant/android/blob/master/app/src/full/java/io/homeassistant/companion/android/notifications/MessagingService.kt#L1032

Can you reproduce it on the tablet?

[Mincka]

Thanks for the update. Disabling DND before sending TTS is an alternative that never failed in my case. Posting the actions for anyone interested.

action:
  - service: notify.mobile_app_telephone_julien
    data:
      message: command_dnd
      title: 'off'
  - service: notify.mobile_app_telephone_julien
    data:
      title: 🔔 Alarme déclenchée ! 🔔
      message: Alarme déclenchée
      data:
        channel: Déclenchement Alarme
        importance: high
        vibrationPattern: >-
          0, 3000, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100,
          100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 3000, 100, 100, 100, 100,
          100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100, 100,
          100, 100
        ledColor: red
        ttl: 0
        priority: high
  - service: notify.mobile_app_telephone_julien
    data:
      message: TTS
      data:
        ttl: 0
        priority: high
        channel: alarm_stream_max
      title: Alarme déclenchée !