Sending AdaptiveCard v1.1 cause ServiceError on Facebook channel

Version

What package version of the SDK are you using. Bot.Builder 4.3.2 Bot.Connector 4.3.2 AdaptiveCards 1.1.2

Describe the bug

When sending an adapter card using version 1.1 in the emulator - everything works great. When trying the same with facebook channel, the connector is returning 500 server exception with: “code”: “ServiceError”

To Reproduce

send message request to connector: POST https://facebook.botframework.com/v3/conversations/<con-ID>/activities/<act-ID> data:

{
	"type": "message",
	"timestamp": "2019-03-26T10:06:11.8086503+00:00",
	"serviceUrl": "https://facebook.botframework.com/",
	"channelId": "facebook",
	"from": {
		"id": "<ID>",
		"name": "say2eat-test"
	},
	"conversation": {
		"isGroup": false,
		"id": "<ID>"
	},
	"recipient": {
		"id": "<ID>",
		"name": "Bou Tiki"
	},
	"text": "sdsdsd",

"attachments": [{
		"contentType": "application/vnd.microsoft.card.adaptive",
		"content": {
			"type": "AdaptiveCard",
			"version": "1.1", //***********this will not work. 1.0 will work****************
			"body": [] //some adaptive cards body or even empty
		}
	},
],
	"replyToId": "2qtspChXQVAvKQw6RNdMIhqYZQwOpNAYm79NJscsZRvBCgowFTF8E8UgA76pZPKY5zWN7B7RyMdiXe3KlhxJYQ"
}

Expected behavior

the message will be forward to fb channel

[bug]

[v-kydela]

@CoHealer - All right, I tested GroupMe, Kik, Slack, Telegram, Twilio, and Facebook. The only other channel that returns a ServiceError is Telegram, but that channel also returns BadRequest for Adaptive Cards 1.0. The other channels all fail without error when sent an Adaptive Card 1.1.

I hadn’t realized this before, but there aren’t any 3rd-party channels that actually support Adaptive Cards. Except for Telegram, they all just render the card as an image.

@yochail - Given that Facebook doesn’t support Adaptive Cards, I’m changing my recommendation. You may find better functionality by using the Messenger platform’s native template system. This blog post can assist you: https://blog.botframework.com/2017/03/28/custom-channel-data/

[artemious7]

Something similar happened to my bot. It’s connected only to Telegram channel, and it worked fine until some time ago, when it started to fail to send my Adaptive Cards. Then sending them was fine again, and now the problem reappeared. No change in bot’s code during this time. Now I found what the problem was: Adaptive Card (v1.0) contained duplicate id’s for elements, so I removed id’s completely, and now it works fine.