''move_legend'' lost the markers for lineplot and hatch for barplot

Hi there,

The move_legend indeed makes the DIY legend much more convenient and saves me a lot of effort, however, I have two small issues that bothered me a lot.

Here is my code.

g=sns.catplot(x="X",  y="Y", data=data_df, kind="bar", legend=True, facet_kws={"legend_out": False})
sns.move_legend(g, "center", bbox_to_anchor=(.5, 0.05), ncol=3, title=None, frameon=False, numpoints=2)
g.fig.subplots_adjust(bottom=0.25)

Would appreciate it if you could give me some hints.

[mwaskom]

A reproducible example for the line plot is as follows.

What is self? In any case, after editing your code so that I can run it, I am unable to reproduce the issue as I understand it:

For the bar plot, are you expecting the legend to show the patches you are manually adding to the bars? They are not in the legend to begin with so you’d need to modify the legend artists too.

I found an extra issue in bar plot, the blank space was not automatically removed.

catplot has the legend_out parameter as part of its signature and i guess that overrides what appears in facet_kws.

[Milkigit]

Thanks for the update. Interestingly, directly modifying the legend artists of relplot also works for me. The workaround for the barplot blank is adjusting the subplots, which also solved my problem. 😂

g.fig.subplots_adjust(bottom=0.25, right=1)