question-mark
Stuck on an issue?

Lightrun Answers was designed to reduce the constant googling that comes with debugging 3rd party libraries. It collects links to all the places you might be looking at while hunting down a tough bug.

And, if you’re still stuck at the end, we’re happy to hop on a call to see how we can help out.

Scope hierarchy not working

See original GitHub issue

I am wondering how to make hierarchical scoping work (it doesn’t seem to), and if it doesn’t whether a patch to implement it would be welcome. For example, in Qt QML I should be able to write something like:

Item {
    property color defaultColor: "blue";
    anchors.fill: context;

    ListView {
        model: ListModel {
            ListElement { value: "foo"; }
            ListElement { value: "bar"; }
            ListElement { value: "baz"; }
        }
        anchors.fill: parent;
        delegate: Rectangle {
            color: defaultColor;
            width: 100;
            height: 100;
            }
    }
}

and have defaultColor picked up from the outer scope. In pureqml this builds fine but then I get a runtime error of “invalid property requested defaultColor” (shown below). It works if I qualify the reference as parent.parent.defaultColor.

Thanks!

qml.app.js:1959 Context: initializing...
qml.app.js:5688 Context: window size: 394x656
qml.app.js:2003 Context: created instance
(index):42 Live reload enabled.
qml.app.js:1963 Context: signalling layout
qml.app.js:1966 Context: calling completed()
qml.app.js:1908 async action failed: Error: invalid property requested: 'defaultColor'
    at $core.Rectangle._globals.core.core.CoreObjectComponentPrototype._get (qml.app.js:440)
    at qml.app.js:2242
    at PropertyStorage._globals.core.core.PropertyStoragePrototype.replaceUpdater (qml.app.js:636)
    at $core.Rectangle.ObjectPrototype._replaceUpdater (qml.app.js:1382)
    at $core.ListView.<anonymous> (qml.app.js:2242)
    at $core.ListView.BaseViewPrototype._createDelegate (qml.app.js:3080)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._createDelegate (qml.app.js:3439)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._layout (qml.app.js:3552)
    at $core.ListView.BaseLayoutPrototype._doLayout (qml.app.js:2622)
    at $core.Context.callback (qml.app.js:2039) Error: invalid property requested: 'defaultColor'
    at $core.Rectangle._globals.core.core.CoreObjectComponentPrototype._get (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:440:9)
    at http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2242:78
    at PropertyStorage._globals.core.core.PropertyStoragePrototype.replaceUpdater (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:636:2)
    at $core.Rectangle.ObjectPrototype._replaceUpdater (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:1382:37)
    at $core.ListView.<anonymous> (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2242:13)
    at $core.ListView.BaseViewPrototype._createDelegate (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:3080:15)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._createDelegate (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:3439:55)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._layout (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:3552:18)
    at $core.ListView.BaseLayoutPrototype._doLayout (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2622:8)
    at $core.Context.callback (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2039:11)
qml.app.js:1908 async action failed: Error: invalid property requested: 'defaultColor'
    at $core.Rectangle._globals.core.core.CoreObjectComponentPrototype._get (qml.app.js:440)
    at qml.app.js:2242
    at PropertyStorage._globals.core.core.PropertyStoragePrototype.replaceUpdater (qml.app.js:636)
    at $core.Rectangle.ObjectPrototype._replaceUpdater (qml.app.js:1382)
    at $core.ListView.<anonymous> (qml.app.js:2242)
    at $core.ListView.BaseViewPrototype._createDelegate (qml.app.js:3080)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._createDelegate (qml.app.js:3439)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._layout (qml.app.js:3552)
    at $core.ListView.BaseLayoutPrototype._doLayout (qml.app.js:2622)
    at $core.Context.callback (qml.app.js:2039) Error: invalid property requested: 'defaultColor'
    at $core.Rectangle._globals.core.core.CoreObjectComponentPrototype._get (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:440:9)
    at http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2242:78
    at PropertyStorage._globals.core.core.PropertyStoragePrototype.replaceUpdater (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:636:2)
    at $core.Rectangle.ObjectPrototype._replaceUpdater (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:1382:37)
    at $core.ListView.<anonymous> (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2242:13)
    at $core.ListView.BaseViewPrototype._createDelegate (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:3080:15)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._createDelegate (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:3439:55)
    at $core.ListView.ListViewPrototype._layout (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:3552:18)
    at $core.ListView.BaseLayoutPrototype._doLayout (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2622:8)
    at $core.Context.callback (http://172.22.162.66:8080/qml.app.js:2039:11)

Issue Analytics

  • State:closed
  • Created 2 years ago
  • Comments:8 (5 by maintainers)

github_iconTop GitHub Comments

1reaction
whoozlecommented, Jul 7, 2021

maybe rename it to something more readable then, like lookup_parent or something like that

0reactions
tomagercommented, Jul 7, 2021

Super, will submit a pull request shortly with parent renamed. I meant hier, as shortening of hierarchical.

Read more comments on GitHub >

github_iconTop Results From Across the Web

Type Hierarchy scope doesn't work - always shows all subtypes
Type Hierarchy scope doesn't work - always shows all subtypes. 1. To reproduce: ... the tool window shows Foo, Bar and Baz whatever...
Read more >
Scope and hierarchy - Adobe Support
Scope is an important part of Substance 3D Modeler. Learn more about what scope is and how to change your scope.
Read more >
Problems with mdx scope in multiple hierarchy - MSDN
I have a problem with scope function. I'm trying to do something similar at time calculations intelligence, but not based on members that ......
Read more >
AngularJS How: Scope hierarchy for Directive - Stack Overflow
Directive in AngularJS: I find out that the elements inside an element with the directive do not inherit its "scope". For example: app...
Read more >
ISINSCOPE hierarchy level - Microsoft Power BI Community
I have tried to get the desired structure via isinscope. However, I do not manage to get the corresponding value.
Read more >

github_iconTop Related Medium Post

No results found

github_iconTop Related StackOverflow Question

No results found

github_iconTroubleshoot Live Code

Lightrun enables developers to add logs, metrics and snapshots to live code - no restarts or redeploys required.
Start Free

github_iconTop Related Reddit Thread

No results found

github_iconTop Related Hackernoon Post

No results found

github_iconTop Related Tweet

No results found

github_iconTop Related Dev.to Post

No results found

github_iconTop Related Hashnode Post

No results found