Support lock dependencies with lowest solvable versions
See original GitHub issue- I have searched the issues of this repo and believe that this is not a duplicate.
- I have searched the documentation and believe that my question is not covered.
Feature Request
Context
When I am implementing a library, it would be super useful to run my tests with all the supported dependencies defined with the constrains in pyproject.toml. This will prevent errors in production when, for example, I use some new features of a dependency and forget to update the dependencies constrains (this is hard to identify when you are coding).
Because running the tests with all the possible combinations of all your supported libraries is virtually impossible, maybe running them with the lowest versions solvable solution and also the highest (I think this is the default behavior)
Proposal
- add the flag
--use-lowest-versions
to the cli entrypoints (install
,sync
,lock
,shell
, andrun
) - these commands will create and/or use a different lock file
poetry.lowest.lock
- a different venv will be created by just adding
lowest
after the project name like this:{project_name}-lowest-{id}-{python-version}
Main simple use case
In ci do the following steps
- Install environments
>>> poetry install
>>> poetry install --use-lowest-versions
- run tests for highest versions
poetry run pytest --junit-xml pytest.xml
- run tests for lowest versions
poetry run --use-lowest-versions pytest --junit-xml pytest.xml
Note: I would appreciate if anyone has a better name for the flag (naming is the hardest part 😛)
Also, I looked a the code and I think I know where add this logic, I can create a PR if you like the idea
Issue Analytics
- State:
- Created 3 years ago
- Reactions:25
- Comments:16 (2 by maintainers)
Ya, I don’t understand how library authors are not clamoring for this. If you put a minimum version in your dependency, it makes 100% sense to test with that version in case you accidentally use a feature from a newer version of it. Then you can decide to bump the dependency version or re-work your code to maintain that older compatibility. I’ve seen this happen on multiple projects and each would have been saved by testing against the minimum version dependencies.
I went off of @JorgeGarciaIrazabal’s comment and played with here if anyone is curious: https://github.com/davegaeddert/poetry/pull/1
Very rough stab and I’m sure there’s all kinds of quirks that could come out of it. But, it was enough for me to poke around some of my own packages and do
poetry upgrade --min-versions
and then run my tests, and realize there’s usually a problem with the min requirements.