Add a contentType property to the HAL-FORMS template element automatically or by hand
See original GitHub issue@gregturn asked me on Gitter to create this issue.
We talked about how one could add a ‘contentType’ property to a HAL-FORMS template element, either automagically or by hand.
@ingogriebsch Trying to understand HAL-FORMS in more detail and currently wondering how I can control to add a 'contentType' to a 'template'.
@gregturn And we haven't (yet) coded support to populate the rest of the HAL-FORMS fields. Spring HATEAOS has sought to capture a vendor neutral format that can be serialized into multiple media types. That avoids having to bake media type awareness into your application. However, when it comes to media type specifics, we may need to consider adding, perhaps, annotations to fill in the bits like contentType. For example, would a @HalForms annotation be useful on a domain object to flesh those details out? Is that the best approach?
@ingogriebsch I expected that the Introspection mechanism checks if the @RequestMapping on the @RestController has defined a 'consumes' or 'produces' and adds a 'contentType' element to the input and/or output without any further ado. I also checked the Affordances API if it allows me to define a contentType through the PayloadMetadata. Another option would be some kind of additional information on the object which represents the payload (maybe through a @HalForms as you mentioned) but it could be hard to add an annotation on every type of payload one wants to use (how about a MultipartFile for example?).
@gregturn That's a good idea. If you captured the consumes/produces idea into an issue, we can pursue that.
Feel free to change/cleanup this ticket as you wish. If I can help in some way, please let me know! 😃
Original discussion starts here: https://gitter.im/spring-projects/spring-hateoas?at=5d876bbac77f285fb1c25f86
Issue Analytics
- State:
- Created 4 years ago
- Comments:9 (6 by maintainers)
@gregturn I like it! 👍
I’ve coded a patch that adds incoming and outgoing media types to the
AffordanceModelFactory
andAffordanceBuilder
API.SpringAffordanceBuilder
is able to use this to collectionconsumes
/produces
details from Spring MVC/WebFlux methods and embed them in the affordance details.HAL-FORMS can now look up incoming media types and use it to populate
contentType
. Other media types are free to leverage this additional meta data.The changes are as backwards compatible as possible, with deprecations in place, which we should be able to then remove in the 1.2 time frame.
The test controller have been updated to demonstrate this, but it’s debatable if we want to keep those changes. We may wish to have a separate
WebFluxEmployeeController
/WebMvcEmployeeController
that exercises and verifies this feature.Feedback welcome.